Sunshine Coast and Brisbane Accountants - Clarke McEwan Accountants and Business Advisorrs
Sunshine Coast and Brisbane Accountants - Clarke McEwan Accountants and Business Advisorrs

The problem when the evidence doesn’t match what the taxpayer tells the ATO

Clarke McEwan Accountants

The problem when the evidence doesn’t match what the taxpayer tells the ATO


A recent case before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) highlights the importance of ensuring that the evidence supports the tax position you are taking.


The case involves heritage farmland originally purchased for $1.6m that sold 7 years later for $4.25m and the GST debt that the ATO is now pursuing on the sale.


In 2013, the taxpayer purchased Sutton Farms in Western Australia – 1.47 hectares consisting of an uninhabitable homestead, large barn and quarters.


Over the course of 7 years, the taxpayer rezoned the property, obtaining conditional subdivision approval to subdivide the property into four lots with plans for a further subdivision into approximately 15 lots, as well as undertaking sewerage, water and electrical works. The work was supported by a $1m loan from a bank and a further $1.5m from his brother-in-law.


While the property was never used for this purpose, the taxpayer’s stated intention was to use the property as their home, gift the subdivided lots to his daughter and son for use as their own respective residences, and use the last subdivided lot as a memorial dedicated to another child who had passed away.


Without being subdivided, the property was eventually sold at a profit as a single lot in 2020 for $4.25m.


When the ATO audited the transaction and issued an assessment notice for GST on the sale transaction, the taxpayer objected. The taxpayer’s argument was that Sutton Farms was intended to be used as a family home and the subdivision application had no commercial purpose. Therefore, GST should not apply as the sale was not made in the course of an enterprise. However, there were a number of factors and inconsistencies working against the taxpayer’s argument:

  • Local media articles that outlined the taxpayer’s plan to commercialise the property, “with the plans to lease it out as a restaurant, wine bar or coffee house, turn the barn into an art studio and add 8 – 10 finger jetties in the canal adjacent.”
  • Statements made to the ATO during the objection stage of the dispute indicating that the taxpayer intended to subdivide the property to sell some of these lots to repay loans owed to the taxpayer’s brother-in-law; and
  • GST credits were claimed on the original development costs. The taxpayer’s accountant also made representations to the ATO stating that the GST credits were claimed because the intended subdivision and sale of the several lots within the property amounted to an enterprise.


The problem for the taxpayer is that although he did not develop the property in the way he originally intended and ended up selling the property as one lot, through the ownership period he acted as if the project was a commercial venture with a stated commercial outcome.


The importance of objective evidence

Determining the tax treatment of a property transaction can sometimes be a difficult exercise and there are a number of factors that need to be considered. This will often include the intention or purpose of the taxpayer when acquiring a property. However, merely stating your intention isn’t enough, it needs to be supported by objective evidence. This might include loan terms, correspondence with advisers and real estate agents, the way expenses have been accounted for, or the conversation you have with a journalist.

Inspirational podcasts for your business
By Clarke McEwan January 30, 2025
Podcasts are the new radio but for many business owners, there are often not enough hours in the day. Here are 9 to educate, entertain and inspire your next business move. #smallbusiness #podcasts #businessaccountants #sunshinecoastbusiness #brisbanebusiness
Selling your business: what happens once you exit?
By Clarke McEwan January 27, 2025
You’ve sold your business! But what happens now!? We’ve outlined five potential pathways your post-sale life could take, and how they help you find new goals and lifestyles. #exitstrategy #sellingup #businesstips #brisbanebusiness #sunshinecoastbusiness #brisbane #sunshinecoast #maroochydoreaccountants #brisbaneaccountants
Business tips: Using forecasting to help your decision-making
By Clarke McEwan January 21, 2025
A crystal ball would be handy in business. Good-quality forecasting can be just as useful, giving you an informed view of the future of your business and finances. #forecasting #business
Happy New Year
By Clarke McEwan January 21, 2025
Happy New Year to our clients! Wishing you a very prosperous 2025 with time to focus on the things that matter most to you! #HealthWealthHappiness #2025
Five big business challenges for 2025
By Clarke McEwan January 8, 2025
What are the five big challenges your business will face in 2025? We’ve summarised five of the most significant external factors that could affect your business. #2025 #externalthreats #businesstips
By Clarke McEwan December 22, 2024
Happy Christmas! We wish you a happy Christmas and very well deserved end-of-year break. We are grateful for the opportunity to work with you and be a part of your business journey. It has been another year of hard work and challenges for our clients. We hope you will be able to take some time at Christmas to connect with family and friends to recharge and relax. Our office will be closed from Friday 20 January 2024 and reopening on Monday 6 January 2025. From all of us at Clarke McEwan Chartered Accountants and Business Advisors
More Posts
Share by: